Welcome to Coy's Pizza Shop(Nolo)
Coy's Pizza Shop (Nolo) offers a delightful experience for pizza enthusiasts in Penn Run, PA. Located at 11919 US-422, this cozy pizza joint is known for its expertly crafted pies, flavorful sauce, and a welcoming atmosphere. Reviews rave about the delicious, doughy crust that pairs beautifully with fresh toppings, making it a local favorite. In addition to pizza, Coy's menu features tasty salads, flavorful strombolis, and unique snacks like Middlesworth Chips. With its affordable prices and friendly service, Coy's Pizza Shop is the perfect spot for a quick bite or a satisfying meal, charming both locals and visitors alike.
-
11919 US-422, Penn Run, PA 15765, United States Hotline: +1 724-463-9449
Welcome to Coy's Pizza Shop (Nolo), a hidden gem nestled on the scenic US Route 422 in Penn Run, Pennsylvania. This charming pizzeria is turning heads and winning hearts with its delicious offerings and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Known for its delightful pizza, Coy's has quickly gained a reputation as a must-visit dining spot in the region.
Step into Coy's, and you’re greeted by the aroma of freshly baked pizzas topped with house-made sauces that are far from ordinary. Many loyal customers rave about the excellent flavor profile—especially the authentic pizza sauce, which evokes the taste of sun-ripened tomatoes rather than the blandness of commercial tomato paste. Whether you opt for a classic pepperoni or venture into more adventurous toppings, the pizza here promises to delight.
Customer satisfaction is paramount at Coy's Pizza Shop. Reviews from locals and visitors alike highlight the friendly service and quick turnaround, making it a great spot for a fast yet memorable meal. As Father James Cairns noted, the pizza may lean on the doughy side, but the exceptional sauce elevates it. The place also offers a variety of other menu items, from hearty salads to savory strombolis, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Although the restaurant has limited inside seating, it does not detract from the experience. Many patrons, like Zachery Josefik, appreciate the quirky setup, where you can grab your favorites while enjoying the casual vibe. The affordability of the menu coupled with generous portions has made Coy's a beloved destination for families—something reflected in Dylan Gorman’s review, where he emphasizes the value and deliciousness of the food.
What sets Coy's apart is its commitment to quality and community. Regulars like Ruby Shultz make it a point to stop by every time they’re in town, often indulging in both pizza and traditional stromboli—an undeniable testament to the food's irresistible appeal. The dynamic menu also includes hoagies, pizza rolls, and even Middlesworth Chips, making it a versatile option for diners seeking variety.
In conclusion, Coy's Pizza Shop (Nolo) promises not just a meal but an experience. It's a place where great food meets genuine hospitality, inviting you to return for more. With rave reviews praising both the food and the friendly staff, this pizzeria is definitely worth a visit. Come see for yourself why Coy's is stealing the spotlight in Western PA!
Coming from NJ, we've been very disappointed with pizza in western PA. The pizza here is very good. A little doughy, but the sauce is excellent. We love the salads and strombolis as well.
Delicious little pizza joint. Great staff. No inside seating unless you are playing a skills machine though. I'd be curious to try some of the other menu items.
Food is great, staff is great, I absolutely love their pizza!
Amazing Pizza place. You need to experience the food here (many different pizza and other items) for yourself it’s delicious and affordable! Hard to find in today’s economy. Lifelong Customer.
I absolutely love this pizza. Whether I'm buying pizza by the slice, or buying the whole pie. Good pricing. They also sell hoagies, pizza rolls, muffins, cookies, drinks chips, etc... They sell Middlesworth Chips here.
Every single time we travel to visit family, we always get a pepperoni pizza and traditional stromboli and write travel up there often. Sometimes, we get it on the way up and on our way home. Excellent food.
Great spot for grabbing a quick couple of slices or other hot grab and go items. Very good prices and value and the pizza certainly does rank near the top for convenience store pizza.
Friendly and clean atmosphere with many food choices. I chose the pizza which was great, and I appreciate the authentic pizza sauce which was not made from tomato paste but tasted like fresh tomatoes. Definitely will be returning!